The utility requirement for a patent means the invention must be useful: it must have a specific, substantial and credible utility that a person skilled in the field would accept (35 U.S.C. 101; MPEP 2107). Most inventions meet it easily. It rules out inventions that cannot work, like perpetual motion machines, and compounds or genes whose only stated use is further research.
Arcangel AI is not a law firm. Attorney services are provided by independent USPTO-registered patent attorneys and agents. This page is general information about U.S. patent applications, not legal advice.
What is the USPTO test for utility?
| Part of the test | Meets it | Fails it |
|---|---|---|
| Specific | A compound that lowers blood pressure | "Useful as a chemical" or "for research" |
| Substantial | A device that measures blood glucose | A gene fragment whose function is unknown |
| Credible | A new hinge that opens a door | A perpetual motion machine; a cure with no plausible mechanism |
MPEP 2107 (Utility Examination Guidelines).
What inventions fail the utility requirement?
- Inoperable inventions that violate scientific principles, such as perpetual motion machines.
- Research intermediates with no stated use other than studying them further (Brenner v. Manson).
- Biological sequences whose function is unknown.
- Inventions with only an illegal or purely speculative use. The U.S. no longer rejects inventions merely for being deceptive or immoral.
How do you show utility in a patent application?
State in the specification what the invention is used for and how it achieves that use. For chemical, pharmaceutical and biotech inventions, include test data or a plausible mechanism. An examiner who doubts utility must give reasons; you can respond with evidence such as test results or expert declarations.
Utility requirement: questions
What is the utility requirement for a patent?
The invention must be useful: it must have a specific, substantial and credible use and actually work (35 U.S.C. 101; MPEP 2107).
What does useful mean in patent law?
It means the invention has a specific, real-world use that a skilled person would find believable. It does not have to be better than existing products or commercially successful.
Do design patents need utility?
No. Design patents protect ornamental appearance, so instead of utility the design must be ornamental, new, original and non-obvious (35 U.S.C. 171).
Sources
- 35 U.S.C. 101, Inventions patentable
- 35 U.S.C. 171, Design patents
- MPEP 2107, Guidelines for examination for compliance with the utility requirement
- Brenner v. Manson, 383 U.S. 519 (1966)
Arcangel AI is not a law firm. Attorney services are provided by independent USPTO-licensed attorneys. This guide is general information, not legal advice. USPTO fees and rules change; check the linked USPTO pages before you file.