Patentability

What Is Non-Obviousness in Patent Law?

By Arcangel AI · Published · Updated · USPTO figures checked

Non-obviousness in patent law means the invention, as a whole, would not have been obvious to a person having ordinary skill in the field before the effective filing date, even by combining earlier references (35 U.S.C. 103). Examiners apply the Graham factors and the flexible approach of KSR v. Teleflex. It is the requirement most patent applications are rejected under, and the hardest to meet.

Arcangel AI is not a law firm. Attorney services are provided by independent USPTO-registered patent attorneys and agents. This page is general information about U.S. patent applications, not legal advice.

How do examiners decide whether an invention is obvious?

  1. Determine the scope and content of the prior art: the references in the same field or reasonably pertinent to the problem.
  2. Find the differences between the prior art and each claim.
  3. Set the level of ordinary skill in the field.
  4. Weigh objective indicia such as commercial success, long-felt need, failure of others and unexpected results, if you provide evidence of them.

The examiner then asks whether a skilled person would have had a reason to modify or combine the references to reach the claimed invention, with a reasonable expectation of success (MPEP 2141, 2143).

What makes an invention obvious?

  • Combining known elements by known methods to get predictable results.
  • Simply substituting one known element for another to get predictable results.
  • Using a known technique to improve similar devices in the same way.
  • Choosing from a small number of identified, predictable solutions ("obvious to try").
  • Changes of size, shape, material or proportion with no new function, unless they produce an unexpected result.

How do you overcome an obviousness rejection?

  • Show a missing element: no combination of the cited references teaches a feature of your claim.
  • Show no reason to combine: the references teach away from each other, or combining them would break one of them.
  • Show unexpected results: data that the claimed invention works better than a skilled person would predict.
  • Submit objective evidence: commercial success tied to the claimed features, long-felt need, failure of others.
  • Amend the claims: add a feature from your description that the references do not show.

What are the three requirements for a patent? · What is novelty in patent law?

Non-obviousness: questions

What is non-obviousness in patent law?

The requirement that the claimed invention would not have been obvious to a person of ordinary skill in the field before the effective filing date, considering all the prior art (35 U.S.C. 103).

What is the non-obviousness requirement for a patent?

An invention can be patented only if, as a whole, it would not have been obvious to a skilled person from the prior art, including by combining references. Examiners apply the Graham factors and KSR v. Teleflex.

What are secondary considerations of non-obviousness?

Objective evidence that an invention was not obvious: commercial success, long-felt but unsolved need, failure of others, copying by competitors, unexpected results and industry praise. It must be linked to the claimed features.

Who is a person having ordinary skill in the art?

A hypothetical person who knows all the relevant prior art and has the ordinary skill and creativity of a worker in the field, set by factors such as the type of problems, prior solutions, the pace of innovation and typical education.

Sources

Arcangel AI is not a law firm. Attorney services are provided by independent USPTO-licensed attorneys. This guide is general information, not legal advice. USPTO fees and rules change; check the linked USPTO pages before you file.